Take our quiz for $500 off your roof*

Roofing Education Centre

How to compare roofing quotes

Roofing quotes often differ because they include different work, and the lowest number is not always the same job. Use this checklist to see where. Lay your quotes side by side and go down the list: any line one quote covers and another doesn't explains part of the price gap.

The checklist

ItemQuestion to ask
Ice and water shieldWhere is it installed? Eaves, rakes, valleys and around penetrations, or only a few spots?
UnderlaymentWhat product covers the rest of the roof deck?
Drip edgeIs it included on every edge? BC code requires it.
VentilationDoes the quote check intake and exhaust and correct them if needed?
Shingle and systemWhich shingle line, and are matching system components used?
Warranty levelWhich manufacturer warranty, and what does it cover?
Workmanship coverageHow many years, and who backs it?
Repair historyWorkmanship coverage depends on the job. Geoff confirms it in your proposal. Qualifying GAF replacements offer additional coverage. How many repairs do you expect to pay for before the roof needs replacing?
ItemizationCan you see each component and its cost, line by line?
Removal and disposalIs the old roof taken off down to the deck, and is disposal included?
Deck repairsHow is damaged decking priced and approved if it's found during removal?
Insurance and WorkSafeBCCan the contractor show current liability insurance and a WorkSafeBC clearance letter? If a worker is hurt on your property and the contractor isn't covered, it can become your problem. Homeguard's credentials page

What changes the price itself? Read what a new roof costs in BC.

Payment terms

Ask how payments are scheduled and what is due before work starts. Financing available, subject to approval (OAC).

Manufacturer versus workmanship warranty

A manufacturer warranty covers the shingles and other products. A workmanship warranty covers how they were installed, which is where most roofing problems start. Ask who backs each one, how long it lasts and what it excludes. Up to 30 years of workmanship coverage is available on eligible GAF roofing systems.

What to look for under the shingles

Ask every contractor which of these layers their quote includes, and where.

Layer 3 of 6

Ice and water shield

Peel-and-stick membrane on eaves, rakes, valleys and around penetrations, not just a few spots.

Tap or hover each layer.

GAF Silver Pledge® and Golden Pledge®

Workmanship and materials coverage
WorkWorkmanshipBacked byMaterials
Homeguard System Plus jobsHomeguardVaries by product
GAF systemsEligible single-family installationsUp to 30 years availableGAFVaries by product

GAF coverage is available on qualifying systems, not every job. Homeguard recommends GAF and can install most other brands, including Malarkey and IKO. Your itemized proposal identifies the coverage for your chosen work. Material coverage for non-GAF roofs and gutters depends on the product. Workmanship coverage depends on the job. Geoff confirms it in your proposal.

Source: GAF Canada: Residential warranties

As a GAF Master Elite® Contractor, Homeguard can offer Silver Pledge® and Golden Pledge® coverage on qualifying installations. Coverage length and terms vary by level, and on strata jobs the coverage stays with the strata corporation.

We walk you through the current options during your consultation, so you can compare them with exact figures before you decide. Full details: comparing warranties.

Request a roofing consultation.

Start with a roofing consultation. After pre-qualification, satellite measurement and a site visit with Geoff lead to itemized options that fit your home and budget.

Click for home