Take our quiz for $500 off your roof*

July 18, 2022 · Updated November 2026 · 4 min read

Choosing Asphalt Shingles: Compare the Whole Roof System

Choosing asphalt shingles starts with the roof they will cover.

Compare suitable products from different manufacturers without assuming one brand is right for every home.

Begin with the practical choices:

  • Scope and condition, established by a roofing consultation.
  • Expected performance under the product’s stated requirements.
  • Written wind coverage and its conditions.
  • Colours viewed on physical samples.

Then check the details that affect installation and maintenance:

  • Construction: Ask what the exact product specification says.
  • Algae features: Distinguish stain-related features from moss control.
  • Weight: Do not treat weight alone as proof of performance.
  • Fastening: Review the required nail placement and method.
  • Slope: Confirm the product suits your roof pitch.
  • Warranty: Separate materials and workmanship coverage.
  • Wind: Check installation conditions attached to coverage.

GAF Asphalt Shingles

Compare the exact GAF product proposed, including required accessories and maintenance guidance.

GAF Silver Pledge® and Golden Pledge® warranties are available on qualifying installations. Up to 30 years of workmanship coverage is available on eligible GAF roofing systems. Eligibility and written terms apply.

Homeguard is a GAF Master Elite® Contractor. That does not mean GAF is the only manufacturer worth comparing.

Confirm the Selected Malarkey Product

Timberline Architectural Shingles

  • Confirm the current product name and installation instructions.
  • Review wind-related conditions in the current written documents.

Grand Canyon Shingles

  • Confirm the product’s current availability and suitability.
  • Review current fire-classification documents for the proposed assembly.
  • Read the written coverage rather than relying on a general protection claim.

Malarkey Asphalt Shingles

Review the exact Malarkey product literature for construction, algae-related features and available colours. Avoid comparing brands through broad claims about cost or quality.

Manufacturer terms differ. Compare the written documents for the exact products and installation proposed.

Confirm the Selected Malarkey Product

Vista AR

  • Ask for current impact-related test documentation if relevant to your decision.
  • Check the product’s written wind coverage and installation conditions.

Windsor Scotchgard

  • Review the current product construction and maintenance guidance.
  • Check the product’s written wind coverage and installation conditions.

Owens Corning Asphalt Shingles

Ask for current literature for the specific Owens Corning product being compared, including fastening and roof-slope requirements.

Shingle sealing requirements should be checked in the current installation instructions for any product.

Ask how installation conditions will be handled. Do not infer poor performance from the brand or local climate alone.

TruDefinition Duration

  • Confirm the exact product version.
  • Compare a physical colour sample.
  • Review the required roof assembly.
  • Check fastening instructions.
  • Read wind-related terms and exclusions.

TruDefinition Duration FLEX

  • Confirm the exact product version.
  • Compare a physical colour sample.
  • Review the required roof assembly.
  • Check fastening instructions.
  • Read wind-related terms and exclusions.

Start with a roofing consultation, then review itemized options that fit your home and budget. Keep gutter work and secondary repairs separate from the asphalt replacement scope.

← All articles

Request a roofing consultation.

Start with a roofing consultation. After pre-qualification, satellite measurement and a site visit with Geoff lead to itemized options that fit your home and budget.

Click for home